Cream Wafers | An Easy Wafer Cookie Recipe

Cream Wafers are one of my favorite Christmas Cookies! They’re a light, flaky wafer cookies recipe made with cream and filled with rich buttercream frosting.

Cream Wafers in a bowl

Cream Wafer Cookies Are One Of My All Time Favorite Christmas Cookies!

Do you have a cookie recipe that you look forward to making/eating every year? I know I have the ability to make these Wafer Cookies all year long, but it just doesn’t feel right. Honestly they would be the perfect Bridal or Baby Shower cookie or amazing on Easter…don’t you think?

BUT I have only ever had these sweet little Cream Wafers at Christmastime, so for me they are synonymous with the holidays.

I do urge you to make these all year long, though, because they are THAT good!

Wafer Cookies filled with buttercream frosting

What Are Cream Wafers?

Let me break this easy cookie recipe down for you…

Cream Wafers are a simple pastry dough, similar to a pie crust, but made with heavy cream and no sugar. So the pastry itself is buttery and flaky, but NOT sweet.

The filling is where you get your dose of sugar. It’s an easy buttercream that balances out to perfection with the crisp, pastry round!

You can tint the frosting any color you like and even roll them in sprinkles to get extra festive!

Filling Cream Wafers with buttercream

How Do You Make Wafer Cookies?

The “cookies” themselves are only 3 ingredients and the dough comes together super fast!

Chill the Dough!

I know sometimes this can be a hassle, but it’s an important step, here’s why:

  • It will make the dough easier to roll out!
  • The cookies will hold their shape better
  • Allowing the dough time to rest allows the glutens to relax, which prevents shrinking when baked.

Roll the Dough!

  • Allow the dough to sit at room temperature for a few minutes before rolling it out. This will prevent the dough from cracking, and will just make the process easier.
  • Use a rolling pin to roll the dough out to about 1/8- inch thick. Try to get the dough rolled out nice and thin, as this makes the best cookies. The dough does puff up slightly when it’s baked, so the thinner the better for crisp wafer cookies.
  • To cut the dough into circles I used a small 1.25 pastry cutter. But you can use any small round cutter you have…or really any shape you would like!
  • Prick the dough with a fork before baking. This will prevent the wafer cookies from puffing up too much, just like you would a pie dough.

What Do You Fill The Wafer Cookies With?

Really you can fill these sandwich cookies with just about anything you would like! Here are some ideas:

  • Buttercream (as listed in this recipe)
  • Nutella
  • Melted Chocolate
  • Any type of frosting
  • Cookie Butter

Fillings to Avoid:

  • Jam or Jelly, as it will make the wafers soggy
  • Honey or Caramel, as it will squeeze out of the cookies and doesn’t have a thick enough consistency.
Wafer Christmas Cookies

Looking For More Christmas Cookie Ideas? Try These: