Carrot Cake Thumbprint Cookies | Cookies and Cups


Carrot Cake Thumbprint Cookies are a fun twist on two classics! It’s your favorite cake in cookie form filled with a delicious cream cheese frosting.

And if you’ve never tried my Carrot Cake Recipe, be sure to add that to your baking list too!

Carrot Cake Thumbprint Cookies on a plate

Carrot Cake Thumbprint Cookies Turn Your Favorite Cake Into A Single Serving!

I am all about turning cake into cookies. Remember my Texas Sheet Cake Cookies or my Coffee Cake Cookies? Both of those recipes that I created have been huge hits with you guys and all over the internet! I’m trying to make that happen again today with these delicious Carrot Cake Thumbprints!

These cookies are all the flavors that you love in carrot cake, reduced down into a chewy, flavor packed cookie topped with a dollop of cream cheese frosting. It’s the perfect little portion to satisfy your sweet tooth!

Carrot Cake Cookies with Cream Cheese Frosting

How To Make Carrot Cake Thumbprint Cookies

You may even be asking, What are Thumbprint Cookies?

They’re typically shortbread-style cookies and when they’re bake and still warm are pressed down in the center to create a well. You can certainly do this with your thumb, hence the name, or you can use the back of a spoon, which is what I do! Then they’re filled, traditionally with a fruit preserves!

My Lemon Thumbprint Cookies are a more classic thumbprint cookie. If you haven’t made them yet, definitely give them as try!

This Carrot Cake version of thumprint cookies are easy to make and come together quicker than a whole cake. Plus, they’re adaptable! I know everyone has their own preference to what is added into carrot cake and these cookies are a great way to really customize the flavors to suit your own preference. Here are some add-in ideas:

  • Raisins: I use golden raisins in the recipe, but feel free to use regular raisins, or even to omit them entirely, although I really love the sweetness they add.
  • Coconut: Go ahead and add in 1/2 cup shredded sweetened coconut to these if you are a fan!
  • Nuts: Chop up some pecan or walnuts and add them in to these cookies. About 1/2 cup will do!
  • Candied Ginger: You could chop some of this up finely to give these a fun twist!
How To Make Carrot Cake Thumbprint Cookies

How To Grate Carrots

For this recipe, and any other carrot cake recipe make sure to grate your own carrots and don’t use pre-grated. The bagged pre-grated that you can find in the produce section in your supermarket are meant for salads. They are grated too thick and too long to work in cake or cookies.

Just pull out your hand or box grater and use the medium grate option and get to work!

Do You Have To Use Cream Cheese Frosting On Carrot Cake?

Nope! It’s my favorite, but here are a few other options:

Carrot Cake Thumbprint Cookies on a plate with cream cheese frosting

Looking For More Carrot Cake Ideas? Try These:

Print